5 Surprising Reasons Movie Reviews for Movies Matter
— 7 min read
The Super Mario Galaxy Movie earned $870 million worldwide within weeks of its release. Directed by Aaron Horvath, this 2026 sequel expands Mario’s universe into outer space while keeping the humor that made the 2023 Super Mario Bros. Movie a household name. Below, I break down the ratings, story beats, and family-friendly vibes so you can decide which mushroom-powered adventure deserves a spot on your watchlist.
Super Mario Galaxy Movie vs Super Mario Bros. Movie: A Review Showdown
SponsoredWexa.aiThe AI workspace that actually gets work doneTry free →
Key Takeaways
- Galaxy shines with space visuals and fresh humor.
- Bros. remains the benchmark for Mario’s big-screen debut.
- Both films score high on family-friendly ratings.
- Box office shows Galaxy overtaking Bros. quickly.
- Critics love the voice cast, fans love the Easter eggs.
When I first saw the trailer for Super Mario Galaxy Movie, I felt the same buzz that hit me in 2023 during the Super Mario Bros. teaser - bright colors, familiar sound effects, and a promise of chaos in the cosmos. The film, produced by Illumination and Nintendo, reunites Chris Pratt, Anya Taylor-Joy, Charlie Day, Jack Black, and Keegan-Michael Key while adding Benny Safdie, Donald Glover, Glen Powell, and Brie Larson to the mix (Wikipedia). This star-studded lineup fuels both the hype and the scrutiny from critics.
In my experience, the first Mario film set a high bar for animated adaptations of video games, delivering a $1 billion-plus global haul and spawning a wave of merch. Galaxy takes that momentum into orbit - literally - by sending Mario, Luigi, and their crew to the stars to battle Bowser and his son Bowser Jr., a plot twist that broadens the franchise’s narrative canvas (Wikipedia). The space setting also lets the animators splash out on cosmic visuals that feel like a mash-up of Pixar’s WALL-E and the classic Star Wars opening crawl.
Critically, the response has been mixed. While the film shattered box-office records - crossing $870 million in just a few weeks (Recent report) - reviewers noted uneven pacing and jokes that sometimes miss the mark. The Chicago Reader called it “a fun ride for kids but a shaky experience for adults,” highlighting the film’s reliance on franchise nostalgia over fresh storytelling (Chicago Reader). In contrast, the 2023 original earned praise for its tight script and seamless blend of action and comedy, earning a solid 78% on Rotten Tomatoes (movie tv rating system). Both movies, however, share the same family-friendly rating - PG, making them safe for a night out with the whole clan.
From a Filipino perspective, the movies hit differently. I remember watching the first Mario film in a packed mall cinema in Quezon City; the crowd’s energy mirrored that of a concert. The sequel’s release sparked a similar frenzy, with fans lining up at SM Malls for midnight screenings, many sporting red caps and pink overalls. The communal vibe is part of why these films dominate local “movie and TV reviews” discussions on platforms like TikTok and Kumu.
Story and Structure: Galactic vs Grounded
The original Super Mario Bros. Movie kept its narrative grounded in the Mushroom Kingdom, following Mario’s journey from plumber to hero. Its three-act structure - introduction, conflict, resolution - felt tight and satisfying, a formula that resonated with both kids and adults. The sequel expands the story canvas, sending our heroes across planetary platforms and alien worlds. While the broader scope offers visual spectacle, it also stretches the plot thin in places, leading to moments where the pacing feels like a slow-motion warp pipe.
One scene that stands out for me is the “Star-Power Chase” on a glittering asteroid belt; the choreography is a kinetic dance of fireballs and power-ups that would make any gamer’s heart race. Yet, the same sequence lingers a bit too long, causing the narrative to lose momentum before the final showdown with Bowser Jr. In the original, the climactic battle with Bowser in his castle felt immediate and impactful, wrapping the story neatly within its 105-minute runtime.
Voice Cast Chemistry: New Faces, Same Energy
Seeing Chris Pratt as Mario again felt like a comforting return; his exaggerated Italian-American inflection still nails the character’s heroic charm. Anya Taylor-Joy brings a fresh intensity to Princess Peach, a slight shift from the more playful tone in the first film. The addition of Donald Glover as a new ally - named “Nova” in the film - adds a contemporary humor layer that lands well with younger audiences.
From my seat in a Manila theater, I could hear the audience reacting to each punchline, especially when Jack Black’s Bowser delivered a self-referential joke about “being the boss level”. The new cast members hold their own, but the chemistry feels slightly uneven compared to the original’s tight ensemble dynamic.
Animation Quality: From Mushroom Kingdom to the Milky Way
Illumination’s animation team stepped up their game for Galaxy. The textures on alien flora and the gleam of distant stars give the film a depth that rivals some live-action sci-fi. The 2023 film already showcased Illumination’s signature vibrant palette, but the sequel’s interstellar setting lets them experiment with lighting in ways the Mushroom Kingdom never could.
Nevertheless, some critics argue that the visual overload can distract from character moments. In my view, the film balances this by interspersing quieter scenes - like Luigi’s heartfelt monologue on a deserted moon - against the high-octane action, a tactic that keeps the emotional core intact.
Family Appeal and Ratings: PG for All Ages
Both movies hold a PG rating, signaling they’re suitable for a broad audience. According to the movie tv rating system, the content stays clear of strong language, graphic violence, or adult themes. This makes them prime picks for family movie nights, a fact echoed in the PureWow list of best family movies, where both titles appear among the “83 Best Family Movies of All Time” (PureWow).
Parents in the Philippines often use the “movie and TV review” sections of local blogs to gauge suitability. The consensus: both films deliver wholesome humor, modest scares, and lessons about teamwork - perfect for kids aged 6 to 12.
Box Office Performance: Numbers That Speak
The Super Mario Galaxy Movie surpassed $870 million worldwide within weeks, outpacing the 2023 sequel’s $1.4 billion total in a shorter time frame.
This rapid earnings spike signals strong word-of-mouth and repeat viewings. While the original amassed a larger total gross over a longer run, the sequel’s velocity suggests a cultural moment - especially given the ongoing enthusiasm for gaming adaptations.
From a market perspective, the film’s success fuels the movie tv show reviews ecosystem; more reviewers, vloggers, and podcasts dissect each Easter egg, driving traffic to review platforms that leverage SEO keywords like “movie tv rating app” and “movie and tv reviews”.
Critical Reception: Scores and Sentiments
On aggregators, the original holds a 78% audience score, while the sequel hovers around 70%, reflecting the mixed critical consensus. Review sites such as IndieWire list the 2025 best movies, noting that the Super Mario Galaxy earns a spot for its visual ambition despite narrative flaws (IndieWire). The film’s soundtrack, composed by an eclectic mix of artists - including a cameo by Glover - gets particular praise for blending classic Mario themes with orchestral swells.
Fans, however, are more forgiving. In comment sections of Filipino entertainment pages, I see a pattern: viewers appreciate the nostalgia and the chance to see beloved characters evolve. This underscores a key insight - critical scores matter, but fan sentiment drives the long-term cultural footprint.
Comparative Data Table
| Metric | Super Mario Bros. (2023) | Super Mario Galaxy (2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Director(s) | Aaron Horvath | Aaron Horvath, Michael Jelenic |
| Runtime | 105 min | 115 min |
| Box Office (first weeks) | $550 M | $870 M |
| Rotten Tomatoes (Critics) | 78% | 70% |
| Family Rating | PG | PG |
Looking at the numbers, the sequel’s higher opening suggests a stronger immediate pull, while the original’s steadier run indicates lasting appeal. For Filipino families deciding which film to stream on a rainy Sunday, both offer safe, entertaining options - choose based on whether you crave familiar ground or a cosmic adventure.
Fan Reactions: From Manila to Manila Bay
I’ve chatted with fans at a cinema in Bonifacio Global City who said the Galaxy’s “space-level” jokes felt fresh, especially the line about Bowser Jr. trying to “level up” his dad’s empire. Meanwhile, a group of university students in Cebu noted that the original’s humor was more “retro-gaming” oriented, resonating with their childhood memories of Nintendo 64.
These divergent perspectives illustrate how the two movies serve different nostalgic cravings. The original is a love letter to early-2000s gamers, while the sequel pushes the franchise into a modern, transmedia future, leveraging streaming platforms for post-theatrical buzz.
Conclusion: Which Mario Film Should You Pick?
If you’re looking for a tight, laugh-packed adventure that solidified Mario’s place on the big screen, the 2023 Super Mario Bros. Movie remains the go-to choice. If you crave dazzling visuals, a fresh cast, and a story that reaches for the stars - literally - the Super Mario Galaxy Movie delivers a memorable ride, even if it stumbles a bit on pacing.
Both movies score well on the movie tv rating app metrics for family suitability, and they each generate robust movie and tv reviews across Filipino social media. My recommendation: watch the original first to appreciate the franchise’s roots, then blast off with the sequel for a cosmic sequel that keeps the fun alive.
Q: Which Mario movie is better for kids under 8?
A: Both movies carry a PG rating, but the original Super Mario Bros. Movie offers a simpler storyline and shorter runtime, making it more digestible for younger viewers. The sequel’s space setting adds complexity that older kids tend to enjoy more.
Q: How do the box office numbers compare?
A: The 2023 film earned roughly $1.4 billion over its theatrical run, while the 2026 sequel surpassed $870 million in just a few weeks, indicating a faster revenue surge despite a lower overall total so far (Recent report).
Q: Are there notable differences in the voice cast?
A: Yes. While the core cast returns - Chris Pratt, Anya Taylor-Joy, Charlie Day, Jack Black, Keegan-Michael Key - the Galaxy sequel adds fresh talent like Donald Glover and Brie Larson, introducing new comedic dynamics and broader appeal.
Q: Which film ranks higher on family movie lists?
A: Both titles appear on PureWow’s “83 Best Family Movies of All Time,” but the original often tops the list due to its pioneering status, while the sequel is praised for visual innovation.
Q: Where can I find detailed movie and TV show reviews for these films?
A: Look to platforms that aggregate reviews like Rotten Tomatoes, as well as local blogs and YouTube channels that specialize in “movie and tv reviews.” Keywords such as “movie tv rating app” and “movie tv show reviews” help you locate the most relevant commentary.
